Google AI Overview is Generating Potentially Defamatory Review Summaries

28 Oct 2026
by: John Stoneman

Dynamic Websites is the trading name of the Melbourne web design and SEO business operated by John Stoneman. The business is based in Hawthorn, Victoria, Australia, and operates through its official website at dynamicwebsites.com.au.

Dynamic Websites provides web design and SEO services to small businesses.

Dynamic Websites is an independent business. It has no ownership, operational, commercial or other affiliation with any similarly named web design or development company. Its services, customer reviews, business history and reputation relate exclusively to Dynamic Websites.

Can Google's AI Overviews Be Trusted?

Google’s AI Overviews are increasingly presented as authoritative summaries of information found online. But how reliable are they when reporting customer reviews and business reputations?

Our recent experience at Dynamic Websites raises serious concerns.

We discovered that Google’s AI could correctly identify two independent businesses, yet combine their customer reviews and reputational information into a misleading assessment.

This raises an important question: if Google’s AI cannot reliably distinguish between the reputations of independent businesses, how much confidence should consumers place in its conclusions?

Why It Matters

Customer reviews belong to specific businesses. They reflect customers’ experiences with individual companies, not an industry or a collection of similarly named organisations.

Combining reviews from independent businesses creates a misleading impression, regardless of whether those reviews are positive or negative.

For small businesses, the consequences can be significant.

Potential customers may rely on Google’s AI Overview without checking the original sources. An inaccurate summary could influence their purchasing decisions and damage the reputation of a business that has no connection to the reviews being presented.

A review can be factually accurate yet become misleading when Google’s AI associates it with the wrong business.

Google’s AI-generated summaries carry an appearance of authority because of their prominent position in search results. However, that authority is compromised when the information is incorrectly attributed.

Google's AI Identifies Separate Businesses But Combines Their Reviews

Google’s AI Overview demonstrates that it recognises Dynamic Websites and another Australian web development business as separate entities.

A Google search for “dynamic websites reviews” provides the evidence. More concerningly, Google’s AI Overview changes its assessment between searches, making its claims inconsistent and difficult to verify.

Google published the following statement:

“Dynamic Websites and [unrelated business] … generally hold mixed-to-positive customer reviews online.”

The unrelated business name has been removed from Google’s original statement. The name of the unrelated company has been retained in our private evidence. We have no intention of associating our business with theirs even in our articles.

This is not simply a case of Google’s AI confusing two similar business names. Its own responses identify them separately before presenting their reputations collectively.

Google’s AI demonstrates that it can distinguish these businesses. Yet, in the same response, it publishes a statement falsely combining their reputations into a single assessment.

That is a lie.

The statement attributes a shared reputation to two independent businesses without establishing that the assessment applies accurately to both. A customer searching specifically for reviews of Dynamic Websites is consequently presented with an assessment that may incorporate opinions about a completely unrelated company.

The problem is not whether the individual customer reviews are genuine. The problem is Google’s false representation of which business those reviews concern.

Google’s AI Overview is not merely displaying information collected from other websites. It is generating and publishing its own summary, presenting that summary prominently in Google’s search results and giving readers the impression that the assessment is authoritative.

When Google combines the reputations of businesses it has already distinguished, the resulting falsehood is Google’s own published statement.

For a business whose reputation influences customer decisions, that is a serious matter. A misleading assessment can discourage prospective customers and damage commercial reputation, regardless of whether the underlying error originated in Google’s data, its AI processing or its presentation of the results.

Google cannot reasonably expect businesses to accept false reputational assessments simply because those statements were generated by artificial intelligence.

Whether a particular publication meets the legal requirements for defamation is a separate question. But the underlying conduct is clear: Google’s AI has distinguished two businesses and then published a false collective assessment of their reputations.

Dynamic Websites specialise in small business web design. We are based in the Melbourne suburb of Hawthorn and provide services throughout Australia. We understand what it takes to get a small business online at an affordable price and with the minimum of fuss. Along with designing websites for small business, tradies and NDIS service providers we provide online marketing services. Our online marketing for small business extends to Google Ads, Google Business Profile, Microsoft Advertising, search engine optimisation (SEO), content writing and, blog writing.

Give John a call on  0413 432 293  or email to find out more about how we can help your small business.